A $10 Million Education

There is a story that every manager seems to know, even if nobody can quite tell you where they first heard it.

At IBM, sometime in the 1960s, an executive makes a decision on a risky venture, and the venture fails. The loss: around ten million dollars. He is called to the office of Tom Watson Jr., then at the head of the company. He walks down the corridor already knowing how it ends. He is sure he is about to be fired.

Watson’s answer, at least in the version that has travelled the furthest, is this: “Fire you? I just spent $10 million educating you”

Like many business legends, the story comes in different versions. Sometimes it is Watson Senior, sometimes the son. Sometimes the loss is one million, sometimes ten. Some versions have Watson simply asking the man to make sure he had learned the right lessons. Nobody seems to have recorded the original conversation, and I suspect it has been polished a little every time it was retold.

And yet, it keeps being retold. I think that says something. We keep this story alive because we would like it to be true. Because most of us, at least once, have been that executive walking down the corridor.

The interesting thing is that research tends to agree with Watson, legend or not.

In the 1990s, Amy Edmondson, then a young researcher at Harvard, studied medication errors in eight hospital units. She expected to find that the best teams, the ones with better leadership and better relationships, made fewer mistakes. The data pointed the other way: the better teams reported more errors. Her explanation was simple and a little uncomfortable. Those teams were probably not making more mistakes. They were just more willing to talk about them. Where people feared the consequences, errors stayed hidden. And a hidden error teaches nothing to anyone.

That study became one of the seeds of what Edmondson later called psychological safety: the shared belief that you can speak up, ask a question or admit a mistake without being punished for it.

Of course, mistakes are not good in themselves. As the old Latin saying goes, errare humanum est, perseverare autem diabolicum: to err is human, to persist in error is diabolical. I quoted the same line a couple of years ago, when I wrote about my favourite definition of intelligence. It came from Steve Ballmer, who once told a room of students that Microsoft was not looking for geniuses, but for people intelligent enough to recognise their mistakes and learn not to repeat them. Watson would probably have agreed. That said, the line works only if two conditions are met: the person learns, and the environment allows the learning to happen. Remove one of the two, and the ten million is simply gone.

So, if you have just made a mistake, a big one, the kind that keeps you awake at night, skip the question “how do I hide this?” and try Watson’s instead: “what did I just pay to learn?”

The bill has already been paid. The least you can do is take the lesson home.

Share the Post:

Related Posts