From VUCA to BANI

Some mornings, I read the news and feel a small knot in my stomach. In 2023, I tried to give that feeling a name in an article for Legal Business World, which I called “Living in a VUCA World”. At the time, it felt like the description of a particular moment: a pandemic just behind us, a war raging in Eastern Europe, inflation, the first wave of generative AI landing on our desks.

Three years later, it looks less like a moment and more like the climate.

For those who have not met it yet, VUCA stands for volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous. The acronym, based on the leadership theories of Warren Bennis and Burt Nanus, was introduced by the US Army War College in 1987 to describe the more complex, multilateral world that followed the end of the Cold War. Over time it moved from the military to business schools and boardrooms, and it never left.

That is why, in every course I teach and every lecture I give, I end up talking about VUCA. For years, I had not found an acronym that described our reality so clearly.

In the last few weeks, though, I have started adding a second one, because it captures something VUCA leaves out. It is called BANI, and it was introduced by the futurist Jamais Cascio in an essay published in April 2020, “Facing the Age of Chaos”. BANI stands for brittle, anxious, nonlinear and incomprehensible.

Brittle, because systems pushed to maximum efficiency become fragile, and a single crack can travel around the world. Anxious, because constant uncertainty leaves us worried even about things we cannot control. Nonlinear, because cause and effect no longer move at the same speed: a small trigger can produce a huge, unpredictable consequence. Incomprehensible, because sometimes events and data simply exceed our ability to make sense of them.

If VUCA describes the world around us, BANI describes how that world feels from the inside.

So what can we do with all this? I can only tell you what I do.

The first thing is to give it a name. I am a verbal thinker, and putting a label on what is happening gives me a sense of inner peace. The world does not become any less chaotic. It just becomes a little easier to look at.

The second thing is awareness. Once I have a name for it, I start noticing it everywhere: in the news, in my inbox, in conversations with clients and friends. And I start noticing it in myself too. In the tension in my shoulders when the next headline arrives. In the urge to check my phone one more time. In the sleep that comes a little later than it should. Seeing the pattern does not make it disappear, but it helps me react a little less and choose a little more.

The third thing is about how I act. I don’t believe there is a perfect strategy for a world like this one: perfect strategies tend to be the first to break when things get brittle. As a line often attributed to Mike Tyson goes, “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.”

So I try something humbler, and it is the same thing I share with my students. I build some slack into my plans. I keep more than one option open. I try to act with incomplete information, without pretending it is complete.

And above all, I look after my own anxiety. In a world like this, the temptation is to react to everything, all the time, and to confuse movement with progress. If years of qi gong and mindfulness have taught me one thing, it is that a calm, empty mind makes better decisions than a frightened one. And in a brittle world, decisions are what we have.

Three years ago I wrote that we were living in a VUCA world. We still are. We have simply learned what it feels like from the inside. And for that, we needed a new word.

Share the Post:

Related Posts