What kind of leader are you?

In 2015 I had just been selected as a Fulbright scholar for my master’s in the US. As part of the programme, I was invited to an Enrichment Seminar in Boston, with some homework to do first: every participant had to take Gallup’s StrengthsFinder. It took me about an hour and a half.

Like most of us, I was expecting a verdict at the end: leader or not. Or maybe a percentage, something like “85% leader”. What we got instead was a map. Out of 34 possible themes, the test gave each of us our top five. Mine were Positivity, Strategic, Restorative, Belief and Developer. In plain words: an optimist, a strategist, a fixer, someone driven by values, and someone who loves helping others grow. Quite accurate, I’d say.

The real show, though, started when we got to Boston and were asked to compare results. Picture a room full of ambitious people from all over the world, each holding a different profile. I should stress that not everyone was happy about the results. I still remember one guy, who later became one of my peers at Harvard, starting shouting because he wanted Achiever in his top five. A piece of paper had just told him otherwise, and he was not ready to accept it.

I smiled at the time, and I filed the whole thing under “interesting”. Looking back, I understand him a little better. Most of us carry an idea of the leader we are supposed to be, and it is rarely the one we actually are. We pick a model, often someone loud, decisive and always busy, and we measure ourselves against it. When the mirror shows something else, our first reaction is to argue with the mirror.

Still, the map stayed with me, and shaped me way more than I thought at the beginning. For this reason, a few months later, in December 2015, I convinced my girlfriend at the time to take the test too. Her top five: Ideation, Strategic, Connectedness, Maximizer and Futuristic. One theme in common, Strategic, and four completely different ones. Whether we were a good match, I leave to fate. And to Gallup.

Then came the real surprise. A year and a half after the first test, I decided to took it again, this time paying for it myself. The results were slightly different. Strategic, Belief and Restorative were still there. But Positivity and Developer had made room for Activator and Responsibility. In Gallup’s words, Activators “make things happen by turning thoughts into action” while responsibility means “taking psychological ownership of what you say you will do“. Either the test was wrong, or I had changed. Considering everything that happened in the period between the two tests, I would go for the second

For a long time, I did not think much more about it. But a few days ago, talking with a colleague in Marrakech, I found myself suggesting the test, which today is called CliftonStrengths. While explaining why, I realised how much those two reports had taught me. Two things, mainly. Leadership comes in different shapes. And shapes can change.

The first lesson is the one I see every day. There are many kinds of leaders, and everyone carries some form of leadership. For some it is active listening. For others it is taking care of people, healing a team after a hard moment, or simply getting things done. The quiet colleague who always notices when someone is struggling is leading. So is the one who turns a vague idea into a plan by Monday morning. And so is the one who keeps asking “why” when everyone else has already agreed.

That is why knowing your own shape helps, in two ways. You stop envying the kind of leadership you do not have, and you start noticing the kinds that are already around you. A team made only of visionaries tends to dream a lot and move very little. A team made only of executors moves fast, but not always in the right direction. The magic usually happens when different shapes meet. In teams, at least.

Is this a promo for Gallup? No. Although writing this post made me want to take the test again, and see how much has changed in ten years. Maybe Positivity will be back. Maybe something new will show up. Either way, I am curious to meet the version of me the test will describe this time.

In the meantime, there is still a question, and I leave it here for you.

What kind of leader are you?

Share the Post:

Related Posts